We would save quite a bit of money by sacrificing being waited on hand and foot as we would have been at Hidden Beach. Hedonism is not for us, at least not at this point in our lives. Couples Sans Souci seemed lovely, as did Tower Isle. Yes please!
Have fun. After the initial surprise he said he was interested, but that Hidden Beach Resort seemed a little too much to start with. It will rebuild over time but for now there is not much beach to enjoy. There are no beach restaurants.